Example

Review a draft spec for gaps

Findings only — gaps, ambiguities, missing criteria. The spec is not rewritten.

Notes you paste

Problem: users want SSO.
Users: everyone.
Requirements: add SSO.
Success: people like it.

First draft

- High — Users: “everyone” is not a user. Who signs in, from which tenant?
- High — Success: “people like it” is not testable. What observable outcome counts?
- Med — Requirements: “add SSO” does not say what happens when the IdP is down.
- Med — Missing criteria for staff password login remaining available.

Fake example — no real systems. Review before anything official.